The Paper Test

October 25 2019 3 Comment(s)

Have you ever heard of the paper test? The theory goes that if you put a drop of essential oil on a white piece of paper, you can tell if it is pure based on if it evaporates or not. If it does not evaporate and leaves a stain, then the theory states that the oil is impure or poor quality. 

While this test is accurate if an oil has been adulterated with some type of carrier oil, it fails to account for several factors. For instance, some components of heavier oils such as vetiver will not completely evaporate, so the paper test fails to show its purity. Adulteration is an expansive industry, and talented chemists can adulterate an oil without the use of a carrier oil. Synthetic compounds and natural isolates, for example, will not affect the evaporation rate like carrier oil will. 

We performed a simple test in our lab to illustrate this. On the first sheet of paper, we put three different lavender samples at 10:45 am. The first is a pure lavender. To the bottom left, we put the same lavender, but mixed with 10% carrier oil. On the bottom right, we put a lavender sample that contained synthetic linalyl acetate and limonene.

On the next paper, we put three different oils at 10:50 am: grapefruit, lavender, and vetiver. As mentioned previously, vetiver is a heavier, thicker oil which will not fully evaporate. Grapefruit is a citrus oil, which typically evaporates at a faster rate than lavender.

Finally, we did a paper test with pure Boswellia carterii (frankincense) and a Boswellia carterii adulterated with a different species of frankincense at 10:55 am. Since the oil is mixed with a different, yet pure, species, it will still evaporate.

Fullsizeoutput 1772

We checked each paper after 15 minutes.

Fullsizeoutput 1773

After a full hour, we checked again. The lavender showed little difference. On the second page, the grapefruit had evaporated considerably while the lavender looked the same and the vetiver had barely soaked through the paper. The multiple species frankincense had not evaporated as much as the pure sample, however that can be attributed to the evaporation rate of the secondary species mixed in.

Fullsizeoutput 1776

After two hours, the pure lavender and the synthetically-adulterated lavender had evaporated more, however the lavender mixed with 10% carrier oil looked the same. On the next page, the grapefruit had nearly completely evaporated except for some residual orange color. The lavender had evaporated more, and the vetiver still had a pool of oil that had not soaked through the paper. The frankincense paper showed that the pure carterii had evaporated significantly more than the mixed carterii.

Fullsizeoutput 1774

At the third hour, the pure lavender had almost completely evaporated and the synthetically-adulterated lavender was close behind with just a little more of a mark than the pure lavender. The lavender with carrier oil was still prominent. On the second page, the grapefruit still had a bit of a tint but was still nearly evaporated completely. The lavender was also close to being completely evaporated. There was still a small drop of vetiver which had not soaked through the page. The pure carterii had nearly evaporated and the mixed species sample had evaporated more, but was still far from being evaporated completely.

Fullsizeoutput 1778

After five hours, the pure lavender was nearly indistinguishable from the paper and the lavender with synthetic adulteration was almost completely evaporated. The lavender with carrier oil was still present, as expected. On the next page, the grapefruit was visible only by a slightly discolored spot on the page, but it was almost gone. The pure lavender was nearly invisible unless looked at closely. The vetiver had finally soaked through the page, but was still very viscous. On the final page, the pure carterii was almost completely evaporated and the mixed sample had evaporated more.

Fullsizeoutput 1775

After 24 hours, only the lavender mixed with 10% coconut oil was visible on the first page. On the second page, you could still see a slight orange tint from the grapefruit, but it was very faint. The vetiver was still very present at the bottom, as expected. On the last page, the pure carterii was completely gone and the adulterated carterii was almost completely gone.

Fullsizeoutput 1779

As you can see, the paper test is only effective in a select adulteration type. Given that it took several hours for the lavender to evaporate while the grapefruit evaporated at a faster rate, the paper test is also a time-intensive process that requires patience. Testing essential oils is important to ensure purity because at-home tests cannot account for the chemical adulterations that happen so often in the industry.

Comments and responses

  • Mandi Johnston:

    26 Oct 2019 17:13:00

    In this “study” you comment about “pure” frankincense vs mixed. Are you implying that mixed frankincense is not pure?

    APRC Response: Sorry for the confusion. The mixed frankincense was two pure species mixed together (but sold as pure carterii), but the second species that was added to the pure carterii has heavier components so it evaporated slower than the pure carterii sample. The key here is that the frankincense was marketed as pure carterii, but was actually adulterated with a different species in order to increase the volume of the product and the profits.

  • Mia Munshi:

    06 Nov 2019 05:07:00

    Well done, good read.

    Aromatherapy is such an art that cannot be compromised. The healing power of nature and intent of the aromatherapist at its optimal.

    Unfortunately, commercialisation broke the institution of ethics. Sad.

    One must go deeper to understand it’s given composition, origins and delivery of the essential oil notes ( high, medium and low) before blending~more so to understand the need of the client not just by the text from the books.

    Simply amazing.

  • Good information and also do NVM ( non volatile matter) test:

    06 Nov 2019 06:20:00

    .

Leave your thoughts